Sometimes becoming a better leader means letting go of everything you thought leadership was supposed to look like.
A few weeks into working together, a client told me something that has stayed with me.
Her team was laughing again.
She’d been on a call with them, made a mistake and laughed at herself. Suddenly, everyone was joking, sharing ideas and genuinely enjoying the conversation.
It might seem like a small thing to celebrate in a coaching relationship, especially when there were still plenty of business challenges to work through.
But I knew exactly why she was telling me.
Because when we’d started working together, that wasn’t how her business felt at all.
And the biggest change wasn’t her team.
It was her.
When Being a Good Leader Feels So Damn Hard
Let’s call her Nancy.
Nancy had built a successful, growing business with a team of six to eight capable, committed people. Several had worked with her for years, and she genuinely cared about them.
But as the business grew, everything became more complicated.
Projects weren’t always delivered as expected. Communication was breaking down. Decisions kept coming back to Nancy, and despite having a talented team, she felt responsible for keeping everything moving.
She was frustrated, overwhelmed and beginning to question whether she was actually a good leader.
Here’s what made that particularly interesting.
Nancy had plenty of leadership experience. She’d worked in senior corporate roles and had seen firsthand what poor leadership could do to people.
She knew exactly what kind of boss she never wanted to become.
Someone who made people feel small. Someone who used feedback as a weapon. Someone who created fear instead of confidence.
And she was determined her employees would never experience that.
But somewhere along the way, she’d started believing that being direct meant being unkind.
She softened feedback, avoided uncomfortable conversations and sometimes stepped in to fix problems herself rather than risk upsetting someone.
In trying so hard not to become the leaders she’d worked for, she’d lost sight of the leader she actually wanted to be.
And I wonder how many founders are doing exactly the same thing.
You Can Be Kind AND Clear
One of the first things Nancy and I explored was what kindness actually meant to her.
Because I had absolutely no interest in turning her into a tougher, more intimidating version of herself.
Her kindness was a strength.
But kindness without clarity was creating confusion.
Her team wasn’t always sure what she expected. Nancy assumed she’d communicated something clearly, while her employees walked away with a completely different understanding.
Work needed to be redone. Frustration grew. And Nancy became increasingly involved in decisions she’d hoped her team could manage independently.
We started working on how she communicated, gave feedback and created clearer expectations.
She learned that she could tell someone something wasn’t working without making them feel like a failure.
She could be honest about her frustration without making it someone else’s responsibility to manage.
And she could ask questions instead of assuming she needed to have every answer.
That last shift was particularly powerful.
Instead of her team bringing problems and waiting for Nancy to solve them, she began encouraging them to bring their thinking and recommendations.
What do you think we should do? What have you considered? What information are we missing?
She was helping people develop their own judgment rather than constantly borrowing hers.
And slowly, the dynamic began to change.
The Team Wasn’t the Only Thing Changing
We also looked at the structure of Nancy’s growing business.
Responsibilities had evolved without always being clearly defined. People weren’t sure which decisions they owned or when Nancy needed to be involved.
So we clarified accountabilities, strengthened communication and created opportunities for her team to take greater ownership of outcomes.
But something else was happening alongside that strategic work.
Nancy was becoming more comfortable being herself.
She was calmer. More confident. More willing to have honest conversations and acknowledge when she didn’t have all the answers.
And her team could feel it.
Before, they’d sometimes avoided bringing problems to her because they knew how overwhelmed she was. They didn’t want to add to her frustration.
Of course, when Nancy didn’t know what was happening, she became more concerned and started checking on everything.
Everyone was trying to do the right thing, but together they’d created a dynamic nobody wanted.
As Nancy became more confident and open, her team became more comfortable speaking up, sharing ideas and making decisions.
Which brings me back to that moment when she told me everyone was laughing again.
It wasn’t that all their challenges had disappeared.
It was that they were beginning to trust one another differently.
And Nancy was finally enjoying the business she’d worked so hard to build.
What Kind of Leader Do You Actually Want to Be?
I think there’s something important in Nancy’s story for every founder who’s ever wondered why leading a team feels harder than it should.
Sometimes we spend so much energy trying to avoid becoming the leaders we’ve experienced that we never really define who we want to be.
We convince ourselves that good leaders always have the answers, never disappoint anyone and somehow manage to keep everyone happy.
But that’s an impossible standard.
And it’s not what your growing business needs.
Your business needs you to create clarity, develop people’s capabilities, make difficult decisions and build a team that can think and act without constantly depending on you.
It also needs you to lead in a way that’s consistent with your values.
Nancy didn’t become a better leader by abandoning her kindness.
She became a better leader by learning how to combine that kindness with honesty, clarity and accountability.
And because she changed how she led, her team began changing with her.
She didn’t become less important to her business. She stopped needing to be important in every moment.
And somewhere along the way, she got something back that I suspect a lot of founders don’t realize they’ve lost.
The joy of leading the business they’d built.
So here’s my question for you.
Are you leading in a way that reflects who you genuinely want to be, or are you still reacting to the leaders you never wanted to become?
Because your people strategy is your growth strategy.
Want to Explore This Further?
In this week’s podcast episode, I share more about Nancy’s experience and how developing confidence in her own leadership helped transform her relationship with her team.
Ready to Find Your Own Leadership Confidence?
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by team challenges or struggling to lead the way you want to, a Deep Dive Strategy Session gives us two focused hours to examine what’s happening, identify what’s keeping you stuck and create a practical plan to move forward.